Al Brokenshire Remembers Fenelon Falls in Days Gone By
January 14, 2026

Fenelon Falls Salvation Army Band, early 1940s
Originally Published in the North Kawartha Times, circa 1985
“My earliest recollection of Fenelon Falls? I was 4 or 5 years old, and I was walking up the street with my dad. There was a businessman who was so tall I thought he was a giant! It was Foster Kelly. When I would go into his shop with my dad, I would always hang onto my dad’s arm, because I was going to meet this giant.”
So said Al Brokenshire as he talked about Fenelon Falls and his memories of the area. Born in 1908, Al lived on Highway 35, on the west shore of Cameron Lake. “It was tourist property along there, and my dad sold lots for $300, and half lots for $150.”
“When Al was 10 years old, his family moved ‘by Byrnell,’ and Al and his brothers and sisters had to walk 2 miles into town to attend school at the top of Colborne Street.
One of the many interesting things that Al Brokenshire did when he was young was working ‘on the ice.’ For two months every winter, he and Hugh Graham filled ice houses for the summer months. This process involved heading out onto the frozen lake, whichever happened to be the closest to the particular house to be filled.
First, the snow had to be cleared from the ice surface, and then a marker was used to size the blocks to be cut. Next, a horse pulled a contraption back and forth across the ice, which cut into the surface about a foot. The ice was chipped out, and an ice saw was used to cut out around the blocks. Then the blocks were ‘spudded,’ to break them out.
Loading the ice into the ice houses was a science in itself. The first layer of blocks was put in, leaving about 6 inches between the wall and the ice. This space was then packed with sawdust. The surface of the layer was slicked off, to make it level, and the ice shaving which slipped between the blocks froze. Each layer was added in this way, and when the ice house was full, a foot of sawdust was packed on top of the ice. In this way, the ice remained frozen all through the summer, and blocks were cut out as needed.
“I remember working on the ice in Rosedale,” Al chuckled. “The place we stayed at all week had no radio. At night we would hop over the fence to the neighbours, and sit around their radio, listening to Amos and Andy.”
Al recalled the days when he worked in the hardware stores in Fenelon Falls. First at Heard’s and then at Brandon’s where he stayed until just a few years ago. Al had ample opportunity to observe shoppers, shops and business changes. “I was 40 years old on the main street, and things have changed! To shop in the stores then, it was more like a visit. It was an all day trip for a farmer to come to town to get a grist of grain done at the mill. While the grain was at the mill, he would go into town and play cards at the back of one of the stores, or talk.”
“Al recalled the stores staying open until midnight on Saturday. It was family night, and huge crowds of people would wander the streets, popping in and out of the stores. But no matter how long the family was in town on a Saturday night, the actual shopping didn’t start until 11:30. Then the barber shops would be full of men waiting for haircuts and the checkouts at the stores would be lined up. Needless to say, the stores seldom closed at 12:00.
Christmas was a time when everyone got into the spirit. Men who had been laid off from work used to go to the shopkeepers and offer to decorate their stores if the supplies were provided. Skating parties were common on Cameron Lake. As many as 10 or more parties could be going on at the same time on the lake. The frozen surface was a common means of getting from the west side of the lake to Fenelon Falls. From Rosedale, cedar trees were driven into the ice to mark the way across. In other places, particularly during a storm, getting across was done on instinct and luck.
Al Brokenshire is perhaps best known as Bandmaster for the Salvation Army Band. He started in the band when he was 10 years old, and at 17 was appointed Deputy Bandmaster. At 20, the band was under his guidance and remained so for 50 years. Al is still an active member of the band and lends a hand when needed.
He is very proud to boast of 31 years perfect attendance as a Rotary member, but Al insists that a good Rotarian is not necessarily one who has perfect attendance, but rather who is active in the projects undertaken by the club—something which Al can also pride himself on.
Still active today, Al says he sometimes gets lonesome for yesterday, when things weren’t so rushed, and people had time to stop and talk.
Al Brokenshire as written by Nora Brokenshire in 1979
Allan Brokenshire began to learn to play a coronet when Captain J.N. Kerr started a band in the Salvation Army in Fenelon Falls Corps. He was ten years old at the time and it was sixty years ago. In a few years he was made Deputy Bandmaster, and at twenty years of age, he was commissioned Bandmaster, a position he has held ever since. He learned to play all of the different brass instruments but coronet has been his mainstay. During those 50 years as bandmaster, he has had probably 75 members, male and female, who have played under his leadership. Many have passed away, some are Salvation Army officers.
Major Joyce Ellery is in Toronto and in charge of several responsibilities in the Women’s Social Services. This work takes her all over Canada and Bermuda. Brigadier Nora Brokenshire, Allan’s sister, was, for over 44 years, in the Salvation Army French Corps in Montreal, where all her work was carried out in French. She also had a small band which she led while there. Jim White is an adjudicator in music in London, Ont., and his brother, Bill is in charge of the Salvation Army Youth Band in Calgary, Alberta. Murray Whitehead is Bandmember of the Oshawa Salvation Army Band which will be visiting Fenelon Falls during the Winter Carnival. Bob Young is the Songster (Choir) leader in the Oshawa Band and the Salvation Army Canadian Staff Band, of which Murray Whitehead was also a member.
This year, 1979, the Salvation Army Band will be celebrating its 60th Anniversary and will be holding special Anniversary Services. A Salvation Army Band, of which there are hundreds in the world, exists only to further God’s work in music, song and testimony.


